omnichannel

Navigating the Evolving Media Landscape

  • OTT 2023

The media landscape continues to evolve, arguably at a faster rate than ever. Leading media and measurement experts presented research-based insights on how viewers use different forms of TV/video on various platforms. Attendees joined us at the Warner Bros. Discovery Studios in California and via livestream to understand the latest data and discussions of the data’s implications.

Member Only Access

MSI Blue Ribbon Report Preview Charts the Future of MMM

  • MSI

The practice of marketing mixed modeling (MMM) is increasing, research finds, partially because of the implementation of privacy restrictions. Today, finding appropriate providers to optimize marketing investments remains challenging. This was the impetus behind the Marketing Science Institute (MSI)’s Blue Ribbon Report on MMM. This free preview of the full white paper outlines what best practices to employ in a rapidly changing landscape. It identifies challenges for MMM veterans and ways to meet them. It also introduces executives to the opportunities that exist when introducing MMM into their firm. The report preview provides a brief overview of the top-level findings found in the full report, which is only available to MSI members.

Member Only Access

Demystifying Cross-Media Ad Impact

In this session, Yannis Pavlidis of consumer insights and CX firm DISQO tackled the challenges of benchmarking, cross-media outcomes and brand lift due to incomplete data from siloed platforms and media channels. In the opening, Yannis provided a refresher on the importance of benchmarks and obstacles from existing approaches to benchmarking (e.g., inconsistent methodologies, outdated data and collection techniques). The discussion examined solutions to address issues in data collection concerning benchmarking ad impact, which streamlines the process using consented, single-source data. The presentation also examined calculating benchmarks based on data taken from one source group (rather than two unaffiliated groups), considered the recency of the campaign used and subsequent behavior(s) which then can be correlated with survey responses. The advantage of using consented single-source data is that it can lead to more insightful, relevant and consistent outcomes in benchmarks.

A Two-Pronged Approach

In this session, speakers Bennett M. Kaufman, Kyle Holtzman and Michelle Smiley of Google explored a two-pronged approach to cross-media measurement and planning that considered the full-funnel impact across traditional TV and streaming video (YouTube), to make sense of all the “disparate forms of data and measurement.” The approach considered a geo-based experiment and audience incrementality to demonstrate and solve the following challenges: to retain current loyal customers, to age down the brand and to appeal to new consumers (Generation Z). The speakers presented a study done by Google in partnership with Burger King to test a new experimentation strategy to understand and measure the relationship between Linear TV and YouTube. The speakers touted the benefits of this method as repeatable and customizable across a variety of media channels, in addition to being timely, omni-channel and privacy safe.

 

A Two-Pronged Approach

Kyle HoltzmanBusiness Lead Restaurant Vertical, Google

Bennett M. KaufmanCross-Media Measurement Lead, Google/YouTube

Michelle SmileyAnalytical Lead Restaurant Vertical, Google



In this session, speakers Bennett M. Kaufman, Kyle Holtzman and Michelle Smiley of Google explored a two-pronged approach to cross-media measurement and planning that considered the full-funnel impact across traditional TV and streaming video (YouTube), to make sense of all the "disparate forms of data and measurement." The approach considered a geo-based experiment and audience incrementality to demonstrate and solve the following challenges: to retain current loyal customers, to age down the brand and to appeal to new consumers (Generation Z). The speakers presented a study done by Google in partnership with Burger King to test a new experimentation strategy to understand and measure the relationship between Linear TV and YouTube. The speakers touted the benefits of this method as repeatable and customizable across a variety of media channels, in addition to being timely, omni-channel and privacy safe.

Key Takeaways

  • The geo-based experiment addressed the understanding of changing behavior in the physical stores for Burger King, through increased sales related to media spend. This technique gave the ability to measure the uplift between control and treatment to understand media impact. The geo-experiment focused on three KPIs: store sales, store transactions and deal take rate (promotion featured in the ad).
    • Results from the geo-experiment indicated:
    • Store sales generated by linear TV were flat but store sales increased in views from YouTube.
    • Store transactions generated by linear TV decreased while YouTube views increased store transactions.
    • In terms of the deal take rate (deal shown in the ad) the take rate was higher generated by linear TV, though it still generated positive returns from YouTube.
  • Audience incrementality testing was conducted by Comscore (3rd party incrementality validation). Through this process, they wanted to understand if they were reaching a new target audience and if their message was reaching anyone that may not have heard their message on linear TV alone.
    • Audience incrementality testing resulted in the following:
    • Accounting for the target audience of adults 18-49 was critical in the short and long term.
    • YouTube reached 78 million adults ages 18-49. In addition, 34 million of the viewers were YouTube-only, unique viewers.
    • There were 43,365,489 cross-platform unique viewers.
    • 20,680,526 were unique linear TV-only viewers with 64 million total linear TV viewers.

Download Presentation

Member Only Access

Demystifying Cross-Media Ad Impact

Yannis PavlidisVP, Data Science and Analytics, DISQO



In this session, Yannis Pavlidis of consumer insights and CX firm DISQO tackled the challenges of benchmarking, cross-media outcomes and brand lift due to incomplete data from siloed platforms and media channels. In the opening, Yannis provided a refresher on the importance of benchmarks and obstacles from existing approaches to benchmarking (e.g., inconsistent methodologies, outdated data and collection techniques). The discussion examined solutions to address issues in data collection concerning benchmarking ad impact, which streamlines the process using consented, single-source data. The presentation also examined calculating benchmarks based on data taken from one source group (rather than two unaffiliated groups), considered the recency of the campaign used and subsequent behavior(s) which then can be correlated with survey responses. The advantage of using consented single-source data is that it can lead to more insightful, relevant and consistent outcomes in benchmarks.

Key Takeaways

  • Challenges with existing approaches to benchmarks included the following:
    • Inconsistent methodologies across social networks make data comparison difficult when assessing cross-media campaigns.
    • Behavioral data is often aggregated from more than one source, making data triangulation inefficient and unreliable (e.g., comparing audiences that are not the same).
    • Outdated benchmarking data often fails to capture more recent substantial changes in the U.S. consumer landscape and the introduction of Generation Z to the consumer marketplace.
  • Inefficiencies in the benchmarking process are addressed by using the same audience and methodologies across social platforms. Data and information gleaned from surveys and behaviors of consumers come from a single source. In addition, results from campaigns focus on the past three years, creating recency and relevancy.
  • Calculating benchmarks are based on campaigns no further than March 2021. The median lift score is calculated using the difference between the exposed group and the control group.
    • Different categories are considered when specific benchmarks are calculated. In addition, a threshold of 15 brands was implemented to create variety and statistical significance.
  • Audiences surveyed are opt-in and tracked using metered data to assess ad exposure and downstream data. Surveys are provided to exposed and matched control individuals to assess attitudinal changes. Additionally, surveys and behavior can be correlated.

Download Presentation

Member Only Access

Explainable AI (XAI) Helps Minimize the Impact of Errors

  • MSI

The use of AI-based voice assistants is becoming ubiquitous, and this technology continues to develop at a rapid pace. Now, Explainable AI (XAI) can help customers understand things better and help mitigate certain kinds of errors. This research discovered that XAI can help consumers forgive minor social faux pas (violations of social norms) but not minor technical errors (failures of the algorithm interface). The series of studies also found that XAI helps consumers overcome their reluctance to use such AI-assisted technologies.

When Should You Apologize for a Service Failure?

  • MSI

GPS and other new, digital technologies have given companies capabilities like never before. They also bring up new questions. For instance, if a company using GPS can see a small service failure is about to occur, should it proactively apologize in real-time or let it go? Proactive apologizing can backfire, which may cause the customer to perceive this service experience as lackluster, leading to decreased satisfaction, trust, recommendations and patronage. What can be done to help managers decide if and when to apologize, and when appropriate, how to do so in the right manner? This study offers some insights.

Member Only Access

How Bad Is a Bad Product Review?

  • MSI

Ever wonder what the impact of one negative review is on a product? Researchers in this MSI award-winning working paper were able to quantify this recently, from a retailer’s “newest first” review display policy. In technology and home and garden products, a single critical opinion had a detrimental impact that was two-fold, the study found. It increased the probability of continuing to search and to competitors while decreasing the purchase probability.

Member Only Access